Best Arrow Puller: Investigation Of Expert Retrievers

We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.

Imagine being a pro to the level where you never miss a target. That might be a dream for you. But in reality, your arrow hits the tree or some bark. And, you have a hard time pulling it out. That’s when an arrow puller pops up to save the day.

However, if you end up buying the worst product then you won’t be able to retrieve your arrow. In that case, you will be back to square one. Thus, it is always a good idea to go for the best arrow puller in town.

And luckily for you, we got 5 of the top-tier ones just for you. So, you can go over their features one at a time and make your ultimate decision.

On top of that, we even added a buying guide. It will help you understand all the important features to look for in an arrow puller. After reading that segment you will have an idea of what to buy and what to avoid.

Now, if you have your reading glasses on, we can start the article-

Comparison Table

Product Weight Size
Double D’s Magnum Grip Arrow Puller 3.1 Ounces 5.2 x 3.54 x 1.34 inches
HME Hand Saver Arrow Puller 3.5 Ounces 1 x 1 x 1 inches
Excalibur T-Handle Arrow Puller 2.4 Ounces 8.5 x 3 x 1 inches
Hamskea Archery Solutions Arrow Puller 17.3 Ounces 12.25 x 3.5 x 1.25 inches
Ravin R141 Arrow Puller 3.2 Ounces 1 x 1 x 1 inches

Double D’s Magnum Grip Arrow Puller

Product Overview

Introducing to you, our favorite arrow puller of all time, the one and only Double D’s Magnum Grip Arrow Puller. Now, what is the secret behind this mysterious arrow puller? Well, let’s find out on the episode of reviews and feedback-

You see, the arrow puller does live up to its name. It means that the arrow puller offers quite a grip. So, you will be able to hold on to the arrow and pull it out in one whip without an issue.

Now, what makes the arrow have such a good grip? Well, the Double D magnum grip arrow puller has a great ergonomic design. In other words, it has a good enough space for people of all ages to clamp onto the puller.

Thus, no matter what gender you belong to or what your age is you can still use this arrow puller.

Double D’s Magnum Grip Arrow Puller

Moreover, the puller itself does most of the work for you. So, when you pull the arrow from the tree or bark you don’t have to exert too much pressure. Hence, you won’t feel too much pressure on your shoulder.

And the main reason for this benefit is because it is made out of aluminum and stainless steel. These components ensure that the puller is enough to do most of the work.

Besides this, the size of this product is quite compact. In fact, we think that it comes in a pretty handy size. You can even put it in your pocket and carry it around for your own use.

And it isn’t only limited to normal arrows. They also work on crossbows. So, you can use them on quite a number of arrows.

On top of all these, they can be used in any season. So, let it be winter or hot summer days your arrow puller will be right by your side to do the hard job of pulling out the arrow for you.


  • Offers great grip
  • Anyone can use it
  • Don’t have to exert too much pressure
  • Can be easily carried around
  • It can withstand all seasons


  • A bit pricey

Check Price on Amazon

HME Hand-Saver Arrow Puller

Product Overview

Second up, we have the HME Hand-Saver Arrow Puller. Now, this one is another great option to consider. Let us tell you why-

HME Hand-Saver Arrow Puller

The main reason why we like this arrow puller is because of the comfort it offers. You see, it is made of silicon. So, when you try to pull the arrow from any hard surface there isn’t much friction that can hurt you.

Moreover, the sides of the arrow puller have molded finger shapes. Because of that you can insert your finger on the arrow puller and have a firmer grip on the arrow itself.

Plus, it is designed in such a way that it prevents hard wear or tear. Thus, your hand will not be hurt during the whole process of pulling out the arrow. And we know how a hunter’s hand is for him.

Also, it has a snap-clip attached to it. So, you can snap it onto your bag or something and carry it along. That means fewer things on your hand so less hassle.


  • It offers a great deal of comfort
  • It has a holding space for fingers
  • Doesn’t allow hard wear or tear
  • Can be easily attached to stuff


  • The slot at the bottom is too small to fit a finger

Excalibur T-Handle Arrow Puller

Product Overview

Next up, we have the Excalibur T-Handle Arrow Puller. This is the third product on our list and it has great potential.

Excalibur T-Handle Arrow Puller

Now, this arrow puller is specially equipped for the Excalibur crossbows. We all know how the Excalibur crossbows have tremendous power. So, getting them out of hard substances can be hard.

But with this arrow puller, you can simply screw it into the crossbow arrow and pull it off. And with that, the crossbow will be out. You won’t even have to exert pressure to get them out.

Besides, it is the lightest weight arrow puller in the list. So, it will be easy to carry around.

Plus, the whole thing is made of polymer. So, even when you do hold on to the arrow puller you can see that it is quite easy to grasp.


  • Easy to use
  • No need for excess pressure
  • Quite easy to grab


  • The end can be a bit crooked

Hamskea Archery Solutions Arrow Puller

Product Overview

On number four, we have the Hamskea Archery Solutions Arrow Puller. So, what does this arrow puller bring to the table?

Well, if you do end up using this arrow puller you won’t have to bend your hand to get the arrow out. That is because they are designed to ensure a straight pull-out.

And thanks to this, the arrow doesn’t suffer much damage. Plus, this arrow puller ensures that you don’t have to exert excess pressure on the arrow. Hence, even kids and women can work with it.

Hamskea Archery Solutions Arrow Puller

Moreover, you can use this to pull the arrow out from wood as well. They will allow you to have enough power to get an arrow out. Be it from a soft or from a hard surface like the bark of trees.


  • Easy to pull
  • Everyone can use it
  • Doesn’t cause damage to the arrow


  • It’s a bit heavy

Ravin R141 Arrow Puller

Product Overview

Last but not least, we have the Ravin R141 Arrow Puller. And without wasting any time, we will reveal to you all the secret mysteries this one holds-

Well, this one allows you to pull the arrow with ease. Thus, you won’t feel any discomfort while pulling the arrow out.

Ravin R141 Arrow Puller

Besides, the thing is ergonomically designed. So, you will have enough holding space. Hence, it will feel comfortable to use.

Plus, the size is quite compact. In fact, it measures 1x1x1 inches. So, you can fit it anywhere. Starting from your pocket to even the arrow shaft. Thus, it is easy to carry around.


  • Easy to carry around
  • Comfortable to use
  • Quite easy to pull out the arrow


  • Can’t pull heavy arrows

Buying Guide

Are you still confused about which arrow puller to go with? Well, since all of them mostly offer the same thing, it can be a hard choice to make. But at the end of the day, you still have to pick something.

However, the pain is that it still has to be a product that works well. So, you might ponder for a long time. And, what can help you in this case?

All you need is some basic info! You see, going over the things that must be present in an arrow puller can give you a clear idea. It will help you determine what to get and which one to avoid.

So, join us as we go over the basic features one at a time-

Grip Of The Arrow Pullers

First and foremost, you need to pay heed to the grip of the arrow puller. You see, the arrow puller has to be designed in such a way that you should be able to have a firm grip.

Otherwise, you won’t be able to get the arrow out of a tree or a hard bark. That is because you can’t hold on to the arrow while pulling it. And, the grip is an important factor for getting the arrow out of the bark.

Well, that is the whole point of an arrow puller. Now, how will you know which one offers more grip?

Simple, all you have to do is hold it and try to pick up arrows with it. If it feels right then it has a strong grip. You’ll be able to tell from just touching the arrow puller.

In our opinion rubber is the best material to use. They offer more grip than any other material out there.

Besides, try to make sure that the arrow puller is ergonomically designed. This means that the arrow puller should have enough curve for the person to put their hand on the arrow.

Durability Factor

Next up you should look at the durability factor. In other words, try to get an arrow puller that lasts a long time. You see, people who take up hunting as a hobby don’t want to buy the parts that frequently.

We all know that it is a drag.

Hence, you can always opt for stuff of premium quality. Don’t go for the cheaper ones because typically they don’t last long. And, you have to go all the way to the store to buy new ones. That is a hassle that everyone wants to avoid.

Weight of The Arrow Pullers

Yes, the weight of the arrow puller also matters. This is because you will have to carry the arrow puller around when you go out hunting. Sometimes, you also have to carry it in your hand when you’re going into the woods.

So, it is a hassle to carry heavy ones. Typically, the metal ones are the heaviest ones. Do avoid them if they weigh too much. Besides, the portability increases by quite a ton if you use the light ones.

User-Friendly Attribute

Last but not least, you have to ensure that the arrow puller has user-friendly attributes. Meaning that it should be easy to use and shouldn’t be too complicated in nature.

Sometimes, in order to make the whole thing a bit fancy, people add extra features to it. Like some arrow pullers have external clenchers that make them a bit harder to use.

So, it can be tricky for beginners. Thus, based on your experience level you should buy the arrow puller.


Question: Can you make a homemade arrow puller?

Answer: Yes, all you need is some soap and gloves. Rub the soap on top of the arrow puller and make it slippery in order to pull it out. While pulling on the arrow use a glove for some firm grip. Now, this is a temporary fix so it might not work too well.

Question: What are arrow pullers made of typically?

Answer: Well, arrow pullers are made of different materials. They can be made of aluminum, steel, silicon, or even rubbers. But we suggest using the rubber ones since they offer more grip.

Question: Why are rubber arrow pullers the best?

Answer: The rubber arrow pullers can deform to take on the share of the arrow. Plus, they have more traction which makes them easier to grip. Hence, the arrow comes out pretty smoothly.

To Sum Up

That marks the end of our guide of the best arrow puller in the market. Now, the choice is in your hand. Besides, you can even make your own arrow puller. But we would suggest you go and buy an original arrow puller.

Besides, they are quite affordable and widely available. Plus, they were built for the sole purpose of getting arrows out of hard places. Anyway, this is all from our side. Tata!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top